Chapter Two with the exception of occasional exaggerations reflects the historical record quite well. In a few cases conclusions from the facts cited in the record are set forth, for which supporting documentation would be difficult to muster. For example: CBPH 42.7
“From childhood to middle age she enjoyed few periods without some physical or mental suffering” (page 31). It is true that Mrs. White was often afflicted with illness, but the statement is too sweeping. The early years were hard. During her pregnancies she was often quite ill. But she frequently writes of being blessed with good health. In September, 1850, she declared, “We are all quite well here now.” (Letter 14, 1850). In November, 1850, she informed some friends, “James and my health is quite good now.” (Letter 28, 1850). Again, in August, 1853, she wrote, “My health is quite good,” (Letter 6, 1853), while a month later she was well enough to act as nurse to a houseful of sick people. She told the Loughboroughs, “I have felt thankful that my health is so good, but I am getting worn out.” (Letter 8, 1853). CBPH 42.8
Similar comments may be found scattered all through her correspondence. Through middle life, as a rule, she enjoyed good health. Like most of us, she was apparently inclined to mention the periods of suffering and remained fairly silent when all went well. CBPH 42.9